1 / 23
For Sale
View on Cars.com2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
8,176 mi·automatic
Backroad Analysis
High ConfidenceFair Price
Listing Price
$374,991
Fair Value
$184,309
C
48/100Backroad Tier
Over Fair Value
-$190,682
See full analysis
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
VIN:
Backroad Analysis
High ConfidenceFair Price
+1.0% vs marketHolding Steady
Listing Price
$374,991
Backroad Fair Value
$184,309
Negative Equity
-$190,682
3-Year Projected
$184,102
C48/100
C-Tier
Enthusiast car, not a collectible
Why It’s a Fair Price
Backroad Valuation
$184,309
LowHigh
$139,886$238,375
High confidence84% of comparable sales land in this range
Car Value Estimate
Listing Price
$374,991
Fair Value
$184,309
Negative Equity
-$190,682
Low
$169,564
Fair Value$184,309
High
$374,991
Value since new — 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
See how we calculated this
Value Forecast
Projected miles at year 5
10,901
≈ 545 mi/yr going forward
Preserved · 8,176Observed · 10,901Heavy · 133,176
+1y
~8,721 mi
+3y
~9,811 mi
+5y
~10,901 mi
1-Year Estimate
$186,791
+1.3%
$137,462 – $246,826
3-Year Estimate
$184,102
-0.1%
$126,730 – $253,928
5-Year Estimate
$184,091
-0.1%
$118,864 – $263,477
Projected value with confidence range over 1, 3, and 5 years
ProjectedHigh / LowConfidence range
Backroad Spec Score
Top 0%
Among 293 tracked Italia examples
Very Rare ConfigurationBackroad Spec Intelligence
Color & Specification
Exterior and interior colors with rarity and value impact
Features & Options
How each feature impacts this car's value
Adds Value
Hurts Value
Seller
Unknown Seller
UnknownTampa, FL
Similar Cars
Active listings that match this car's trim, year, and mileage
For Sale
2013 Ferrari 458
Italia · 8,394 mi
Asking
$419,999
Fair Value
$171,474
cars_comView Details
For Sale
2014 Ferrari 458
Italia · 7,853 mi
Asking
$398,888
Fair Value
$204,107
cars_comView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 7,824 mi
Asking
$389,999
Fair Value
$170,811
dupontView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 7,066 mi
Asking
$349,950
Fair Value
$180,882
hemmingsView Details
For Sale
2013 Ferrari 458
Italia · 6,961 mi
Asking
$439,995
Fair Value
$192,267
cars_comView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 6,020 mi
Asking
$359,990
Fair Value
$198,378
dupontView Details
For Sale
2013 Ferrari 458
Italia · 10,894 mi
Asking
$401,689
Fair Value
$187,534
cars_comView Details
For Sale
2013 Ferrari 458
Italia · 5,226 mi
Asking
$399,999
Fair Value
$199,047
hemmingsView Details
For Sale
2010 Ferrari 458
Italia · 11,521 mi
Asking
$309,900
Fair Value
$180,521
cars_comView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 4,768 mi
Asking
$449,995
Fair Value
$196,519
ferrari_approvedView Details
For Sale
2013 Ferrari 458
Italia · 11,880 mi
Asking
$299,000
Fair Value
$187,401
exotics_hunterView Details
For Sale
2014 Ferrari 458
Italia · 3,913 mi
Asking
$399,999
Fair Value
$255,833
cars_comView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 3,910 mi
Asking
$599,995
Fair Value
$190,209
dupontView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 12,529 mi
Asking
$299,995
Fair Value
$174,425
cars_comView Details
Save $14,709
For Sale
2009 Ferrari 458
Italia · 3,400 mi
Asking
$235,000
Fair Value
$249,709
ferrarichatView Details
For Sale
2012 Ferrari 458
Italia · 13,100 mi
Asking
$275,000
Fair Value
$230,092
exotics_hunterView Details
For Sale
2013 Ferrari 458
Italia · 13,802 mi
Asking
$349,990
Fair Value
$190,824
dupontView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 14,183 mi
Asking
$356,795
Fair Value
$200,490
ferrari_approvedView Details
For Sale
2011 Ferrari 458
Italia · 14,408 mi
Asking
$362,795
Fair Value
$169,443
ferrari_approvedView Details
The source of truth for enthusiast cars
Every listing, every spec, every edge. Market intelligence built for enthusiasts by enthusiasts.