ListingsDealersCompareInsightsValue My Car
Sign InSign Up
Italia
Ferrari458458Italia2011 Italia
1 / 36
For Sale
View on Cars.com

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

25,543 mi·automatic·Argento Nurburgring·Grigio Scuro Leather
Backroad Analysis
High Confidence
Fair Price

Listing Price

$259,999

Fair Value

$202,868

C
47/100Backroad Tier

Over Fair Value

-$57,131

See full analysis
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

25,543 mi · automatic · rwd · V-8

Argento NurburgringGrigio Scuro Leather

Asking Price

$259,999

Fair Value

$202,868

Fair PriceC47-$57,131 over fair value

Status Auto Group, Staten Island, NY

Listed 60 days ago

1 / 36

Mileage

25,543 mi

Exterior

Argento Nurburgring

Interior

Grigio Scuro

Engine

V-8

Transmission

automatic

Drivetrain

rwd

Body Style

Coupe

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

For Sale· Listed Mar 26, 2026View on Cars.com
Staten Island, NYatStatus Auto Group

VIN:

25,543 miArgento NurburgringexteriorGrigio Scuro Leatherinterior
Backroad Analysis
High Confidence
Fair Price
+0.3% vs marketHolding Steady

Listing Price

$259,999

Backroad Fair Value

$202,868

Negative Equity

-$57,131

3-Year Projected

$199,493

C

C-Tier

Enthusiast car, not a collectible

47/100

Why It’s a Fair Price

Backroad Valuation

$202,868

LowHigh
$172,912$239,327
High confidence84% of comparable sales land in this range

Car Value Estimate

Listing Price

$259,999

Fair Value

$202,868

Negative Equity

-$57,131

Low

$186,639

Fair Value$202,868

High

$259,999

Value since new — 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

See how we calculated this

Value Forecast

Projected miles at year 5

34,053

≈ 1,702 mi/yr going forward

Preserved · 25,543Observed · 34,053Heavy · 150,543

+1y

~27,245 mi

+3y

~30,649 mi

+5y

~34,053 mi

1-Year Estimate

$199,715

-1.6%

$166,720 – $239,871

3-Year Estimate

$199,493

-1.7%

$160,490 – $246,961

5-Year Estimate

$200,818

-1.0%

$155,485 – $255,992

Projected value with confidence range over 1, 3, and 5 years
ProjectedHigh / LowConfidence range

Color & Specification

Exterior and interior colors with rarity and value impact

Exterior

Argento Nurburgring

+$5,500

Interior

Grigio Scuro Leather

Not in catalog

-$575

Features & Options

How each feature impacts this car's value

Adds Value

Hurts Value

Seller

Status Auto Group

DealerStaten Island, NY
View original listing

The source of truth for enthusiast cars

Every listing, every spec, every edge. Market intelligence built for enthusiasts by enthusiasts.

Get Started Free

The source of truth for enthusiast cars.

Backroad Weekly

Product

  • Listings
  • Dealers
  • Compare
  • Insights
  • Valuations
  • API

Company

  • About
  • Press

Support

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
© 2026 Backroad. All rights reserved.